Sherwood and Hutsell Law Offices

Alternative
Dispute
Resolution
(ADR)
Our Services
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is the process of resolving disputes outside of the courtroom. Litigation can take months and sometimes years before any resolution is had. Studies show that an average of 90% of cases settle or are dismissed before trial. ADR recognizes the burden that litigation places on people as human beings, accepts the reality that most cases won't be litigated, and takes active steps at the start of all cases to seek out alternative means of resolution before time, stress, and relationships are strained.
ADR provides a heavy focus on dispute resolution skills that help people negotiate, mediate, and arbitrate more successfully regardless of the underlying practice area. Our ADR attorney is ready to assist or facilitate any negotiation, mediation, or arbitration.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is ADR beneficial?
Litigation is often a zero-sum contest. That is, a person either wins or loses. ADR focuses on "creating value" by helping clients focus on desires and practical considerations other than compensation or reconciliation for the immediate action. ADR examines costs outside of traditional costs like time and money. ADR considers the impact that litigation will have on relationships, personal life, professional life, and social capital. These considerations can aid a client in avoiding pitfalls outside of litigation and identify means of settling with opposing parties who themselves do not sense pitfalls in front of them.
How does ADR work?
ADR comes to life chiefly through negotiation, mediation, and arbitration. ADR teaches professionals how to engage with clients and opposing parties in a manner that facilitates productive communication rather than unproductive or even counterproductive argument.
Do you have any examples of ADR at action?
Part of ADR studies is the study of emotions not dissimilar to how counselors, therapists, and similar professionals study emotions. An emotion like anger is defined as a reaction to a perceived direct threat. ADR trains its professionals to identify the emotion and consider how the person is being threatened. A professional may then respond directly to the perceived threat to try and calm the person, or else redirect their emotions to somebody other than the client; a useful act when attempting to settle a dispute.
Another example is that people often speak too much when feeling too much emotion. ADR teaches professionals to let a person talk until they stop speaking naturally. A person who enters a conversation willingly often quiets after an emotional monologue and is more willing to listen to opposing opinions.
These small means of facilitating communication and emotion add together to create environments where people feel validated while vulnerable and so feel safe to expand on vulnerability. Vulnerability is often the key to fostering productive communication. ADR teaches us that "vulnerability" is not an inherently negative state.
An attorney is not a valid substitute for a health care professional and is not qualified to give health care advice. You should always seek out a licensed medical professional if you need advice or help. Always call 911 in any emergency situation. It's okay to ask for help.
What if I don't want to settle or the opposing party doesn't want to settle?
ADR is the practice of reaching settlement. We do not and cannot guarantee that your case will settle. However, ADR is the process of sitting adversarial clients down and convincing them that either a fight isn't worth it, or that neither party is at fault but that life happened.
What if ADR attempts fail?
ADR is multi-faceted and considerations about alternative means of resolution and how the client is impacted proceed through the whole process from the first meeting to the final handshake. If attempts at negotiating or mediating fail, then ADR has a party consider their next best alternative. The next best alternative may be litigation but may also be any legal means of settling the dispute. Creativity is useful for this endeavor.
Why would I want a mediator to hear my case?
A mediator is often a voice of reason. The mediator has no reason to support either party and gives a general idea how a trier of fact will react to the facts laid in front of them. A mediator may act as a reality-check for one or both parties and provide counsel as the mediator sees appropriate. A mediator may also have a reaction to an argument strong enough to cause a party to reconsider pursuing litigation. These reasons and more are why a mediator is useful in many cases and in fact, some court cases will have mandatory mediation because of how useful the process can be to resolution without costly and emotional trial.
Why would I want an arbiter to decide my case?
You might not want an arbiter to decide your case. Arbitration is binding and if a case is legally strong than representation at a court of law may be the considerably stronger option for recovery. Yet, arbitration was created in spirit to be a cheaper, easier, and less-stressful means of litigation for citizens. Arbitration is meant to let opposing sides go before a neutral party to determine judgment based on what the parties say without the complicated and nuanced procedure that accompanies litigation. Talk to an attorney for legal counsel to determine if arbitration is right for you.
Who can act as mediator or arbiter?
Generally any party can act as a mediator or arbiter by agreement of the parties unless a contractual provision or court orders requires the mediator or arbiter to have particular credentials. A mediator should generally be versed in dispute resolution techniques to foster resolution as no binding judgment may be issued by a mediator. An arbiter should generally be qualified in the subject matter being disputed as their decision is final and cannot usually be appealed. However, any person that displays an ability to grasp the dispute and render credible analysis and fair judgment may be a good option. Mediators and arbiters are allowed to and encouraged to provide equitable resolutions that are compromises when they feel that both parties have reasonable grievances and defenses or justifications for their actions.
What is the difference between negotiation, mediation, arbitration?
Negotiation is a process of good faith communication where the parties exchange subjective desires while considering objective needs. The goal of negotiation is not to "give away" what is deserved but to either "create value" or manage loss in a manner that lets all parties walk away with more than they would after litigation. Negotiation is a process that involves the opposing parties communicating directly or through agents. Negotiations too often take the form of adversarial demands rather than productive communication and compromise. ADR reminds clients that the act of negotiating involves two parties with subjective wants and needs and includes an objective reality with consequences for action. Negotiation is the act of navigating those wants and needs to create something called a Zone of Possible Agreement. The objective reality often determines where the final agreement rests.
Mediation is facilitated negotiation. A neutral third-party called a mediator leads negotiations and acts as a voice of reason for the parties. A mediator encourages equitable resolution through varying means while discouraging non-productive bickering. The perks of having a mediator are discussed above.
Arbitration is binding facilitated negotiation. A neutral third-party called an arbiter leads negotiations and acts as a judge and jury. The arbiter's decision is final and generally cannot be appealed in a court of law. The perks of a arbitration are discussed above.
I have a different question.
Have a question that wasn't answered above? Our offices are ready and able to answer your questions. Call us or submit a contact request for help today.